OK, so my wife tried a friend's plastic SUP this weekend and really enjoyed it, even though she never got past the kneeling position to standing. It was one of the pretty standard 10' plastic ones. I know from a Sassafras and Skerry how strong and light the CLC epoxy/ply designs are. And was a bit surprised at the high prices on decent looking plastic SUPs.
So, for a woman in, well her 50s, with a reasonable fitness level (lots of yoga and figure skating) but zero experience w/ these things, who's a pretty solid 150 lbs, is the Kaholo 12-6 or the 14 a better bet. It looks like either will be significantly lighter that most of the plastic boards. Stability, ease of carry and ease of paddling in calmish waters, no surfing, are the important criteria. She does have a shoulder that she sprained years ago which acts up, so I'm thinking the ease of paddling and light weight are key. The size guidance on the product page puts her in that middle ground overlap of the two sizes. Opinions anybody?