[NED] Tiller arm broken off of rudder – repair approach?

In a somewhat freak combination of events, I was walking my NE Dory along a dock in choppy water when the tiller arm got caught in a railing and snapped off from rudder head. I’m a pretty novice boat maker, so I’m looking for advice on repair.

Could it be as easy as epoxying the wound and clamping tight. Will that give me enough strength? Or should I grind out the fillet and re-fillet along the broken edge, as well? Should I attempt to add 1/4 inch dowels through the rudder into the arm – or would that do more harm than good? Do I need to lay fiberglass along the rudder extension – that seems like much bigger endeavor that I’d prefer to avoid, at least until winter (e.g., removing varnish, adding glass, epoxy, more epoxy, sanding, varnishing, etc)?

Here are two pictures of the damage: https://i.imgur.com/99C1qWH.jpeg and https://i.imgur.com/KvDUVij.jpeg .

Any advice would be much appreciated!

I’ve attached some pictures. I didn’t like the idea of having to store or transport a fixed L-shaped piece that was the rudder stock/arm arrangement as per original NE Dory plans. During initial construction I added a bit of reenforcement and thickness to the top of the rudder head and used an oak dowell (1 or 1.25 inches diameter, can’t remember which) to place through the hole I drilled for it. I also didn’t like the idea of possibly breaking the long spruce tiller stick, so substituted a piece of rattan pole - very durable and flexible. The joint between the two is a simple line through a 5/16 hole drilled through both, then easily lashed. You’ll note the lashing at the rudder head, too. Finally, you’ll see one picture taken after sailing the boat for 5 years - I modified the rudder pivot angle by adding a fin to the transom, and modified the rudder shape. You can find my discussion of that mod elsewhere in the forum. Again, I think it an improvement. All things you might consider. I really like being able to easily disassemble the rudder from the tiller arm pieces and easily store and transport everything, or if I’m in for a long row with all the sailing gear stowed onboard.

I neglected to mention there is a hole drilled through the tiller ling piece (with the line placed through that hole) , too. The hole/line through it establishes how far into the head the tiller link piece can be pushed before you start lashing. Thus that lashing is “captured” - it doesn’t show in the pictures, but the tiller link piece cannot be pulled out throught the rudder head due to this arrangement.

1 Like

Also neglected to mention that I did fiberglass the top half of the rudder head/cheeks during initial construction,.

@Jeff_Richards thank you for the suggestion. That looks pretty slick. I also am not a fan of a large l-shaped contraption to manage.

Do you find that arrangement stays tight? If I understand correctly, the hole you mentioned keeps the dowel from pulling out via the stubby end, but it’s just the friction of the lashing that keeps the dowel from loosening up on long end. Or do you have a hole in the dowel on both sides of the rudder?

Thanks

My tiller piece stays very tight. I kept the tolerance tight when building - had to sand to final circumference to get it to fit into the hole through the rudder head. And there is no varnish or finish on the end of the dowell, just waxed wood. Depending on humidity or temperature or getting it wet, at times I’ve found it so tight I had to use some chapstick as emergency lube to make is slick enough to make it slip together. Mine is drilled through on the “long” end, thus the line being through that hole sets the depth as to how far it will insert into the rudder head. I never take the line out of that hole when de-rigging. On the short (stubby) end I used a rat-tail rasp to make a little half-round groove about 1/8 inch deep around the dowell, just at the point where the first turn of a clove hitch will lay into it alongside the rudder head. So when I rig I do a once up and over (to get to the stubby side), tie a clove hitch (with the first turn down in the groove), then back up and over (returning to the side with the hole) and the tie another clove hitch. There is no way the dowell can be pulled out of the rudder head with this arrangement - in hindsight the groove probably wasn’t even necessary, but probably adds a little security. The dowell will rotate sufficiently to allow your long tiller piece to be moved up and down. I use a rope joint between the two tiller pieces, but that is a little sloppy and the rope tends to wear a bit from the shear loading being placed on the rope. A bolt would work fine there, if desired. Use a nylock nut so that it doesn’t half to be tightened beyong just tight enough, and probably with a teflon washer between the two tiller pieces, if you go the bolt route for that joint.